Home Back

ENGLAND PLAYER RATINGS: Which player was 'petulant and pedestrian'?

Daily Mail Online 3 days ago

England ended their group stage campaign at Euro 2024 not with a bang, but with a whimper in their 0-0 draw with Slovenia on Tuesday evening. 

With the other Group C tie - Denmark's clash with Serbia - also ending goalless, Gareth Southgate's side will finish at the top of the pile, but the head coach will have much to reflect on as the team prepares for their Round of 16 match. 

Bukayo Saka found the back of the net in halfway inside the first-half, but had the effort chalked off by VAR, and none of his team-mates were able to better his efforts as the game progressed. 

The second-half saw Conor Gallagher exchanged for Kobbie Mainoo, and another positive start, but ultimately neither side were capable of breaking the deadlock.  

Here, Craig Hope runs the rule over England's individuals - and assesses who came out best on a challenging night in Germany.  

England may have topped their group but the final whistle blew on a sobering group stage run
England may have topped their group but the final whistle blew on a sobering group stage run
Some players looked anonymous as England failed to find the back of the net vs Slovenia
Some players looked anonymous as England failed to find the back of the net vs Slovenia
Gareth Southgate will have much to ponder as he prepares for the knockout stages this week
Gareth Southgate will have much to ponder as he prepares for the knockout stages this week

ENGLAND (4-1-4–1)

Jordan Pickford 6

He was largely a spectator, but he can’t be enjoying watching what is in front of him. Routine involvements were completed with minimum fuss and another clean sheet. The problems with this team rest elsewhere. Does he fancy playing on the left?!

Kyle Walker 5

Was sloppy on the ball at times and wasted one brilliant chance to cross or shoot when slicing a ball from Kane straight out of play inside area. When it’s all so slow England need his pace to disrupt the opposition, and it just didn’t happen.

John Stones 5.5

Shanked one into the stands early on and then miscontrolled another out of play. He did not step into midfield to get on the ball either, but when it’s all so stodgy in front of him that is difficult. Did fine defensively, not that they were tested much.

Marc Guehi 6

Among those to gift the ball to Slovenia during shaky start but dealt well with Sesko thereafter and it was another solid display until mistake that would have left Slovenia in if not for his subsequent foul, for which he was booked. Has done well here, but there’s always one error in him, you feel.

Kieran Trippier provided some crosses but still looks less than perfection at left-back for team
Kieran Trippier provided some crosses but still looks less than perfection at left-back for team
Marc Guehi almost handed Slovenia a straightforward attack but grew into a solid display
Marc Guehi almost handed Slovenia a straightforward attack but grew into a solid display

Kieran Trippier 6

He played a couple of teasing crosses that deserved more and at least that provided some threat. He had to manage his game after first-half yellow and did so well. It’s not ideal him being at left back, but he’s making the best of a bad job,

Declan Rice 5.5

Some good, some bad. He certainly gave his all and tried to take England forward second half, but this was another performance unrecognisable from what he produces for Arsenal. His frustration was evident late on as he looked to the skies.

Bukayo Saka 4.5

Not involved enough and suspicion remains he is not fully fit. This version of Saka is not the England star of previous tournaments. He’s doing well to stay in the team and his withdrawal on 71 minutes was long overdue. Followed familiar pattern of fading fast in games.

Conor Gallagher 5

Brutally hooked at half-time. He hadn’t been great but that felt harsh, given he was Southgate’s only change to starting XI. Failed to connect with his head from glorious Trippier cross that would have been a goal and ran around without offering anything by way of guile, but we knew that already.

Conor Gallagher (pictured centre) was drafted in for Trent Alexander-Arnold but failed to dazzle in his stead
Conor Gallagher (pictured centre) was drafted in for Trent Alexander-Arnold but failed to dazzle in his stead
Bukayo Saka thought he had found the back of the net but had his goal ruled out via VAR
Bukayo Saka thought he had found the back of the net but had his goal ruled out via VAR
Jude Bellingham may not feel as secure in Southgate's starting XI as he previously might have
Jude Bellingham may not feel as secure in Southgate's starting XI as he previously might have 

Jude Bellingham 4

He was either losing the ball or missing challenges first half. Where was the superstar from the opening game? Petulant and pedestrian, he threw his arms up at one point and glared at bench. Shifted left for period second half but nothing improved. His place in team should not be guaranteed.

Phil Foden 7

Easily England’s brightest attacking spark, so why not play him where he wants - in the middle - from the start? Others weren’t on same wavelength with some of his one-touch passing and he was clearly frustrated with team-mates, and understandably so. England’s best on another bad night for team.

Harry Kane 5

Sluggish start, again. At one point Foden called for him to be on his toes after not reading a clever pass. Shots from distance that were either blocked or easily saved. Got better second half but best work was in areas other than centre-forward.

Substitutes

Kobbie Mainoo (on for Gallagher 46) 6

Offered more dynamism than Gallagher and at least tried to make things happen, even if they didn’t. Enough to suggest he is worth keeping in midfield for next game, given his willingness to break the lines and break the tedium of England’s play.

Kobbie Mainoo was brought on for Gallagher at the start of the second-half and provided some brightness in his 45 minutes
Kobbie Mainoo was brought on for Gallagher at the start of the second-half and provided some brightness in his 45 minutes
Cole Palmer was another brighter spark but failed to put away one of England's better chances
Cole Palmer was another brighter spark but failed to put away one of England's better chances

Cole Palmer (on for Saka 71) 6.5

Some cute passes shortly after arrival but he was brought into a difficult situation amid largely lifeless England display. He did more in his 20 minutes than Bellingham managed in 90, however, and must now start. 

Trent-Alexander-Arnold (on for Trippier 85) N/A

Brought on at right back but too late to impact.

Anthony Gordon (on for Foden 88) N/A

Finally some tournament minutes but he needs longer than this. One fantastic, incisive forward pass that led to chance. 

Manager - Gareth Southgate 4

Tweaked his system with a 4-1-4-1 but nothing really changed - England were predictable and pedestrian and there is no real strategy to what they do. He should have made more than one change to starting XI and must surely now shake things up. Good players look bad in this team.

Slovenia's goalkeeper Jan Oblak was scarcely troubled during his spell between the sticks
Slovenia's goalkeeper Jan Oblak was scarcely troubled during his spell between the sticks
Southgate must now shake things up as England gear up to impress in their Round of 16 tie
Southgate must now shake things up as England gear up to impress in their Round of 16 tie

Slovenia (4-4-2): Oblak 6.5; Karnicnik 7, Drkusic 7, Bijol 7, Janza 6; Stojanovic 6.5, Cerin 6.5, Elsnik 7, Mlakar 5.5; Sesko 6 (Ilicic 75, 5), Sporar 5.5

Manager: Matjaz Kek 6.5

Referee: C Turpin (FRA) 7

Correctly booked Trippier for first-half foul and he and his team called England’s offside goal without the need for VAR. No complaints with the performance of the officials, even if they were aided by a turgid game at times.

People are also reading