Sandals Royal Bahamian and Sandals Montego Bay are both luxurious adult-only all-inclusive resorts in the Caribbean. But while they have many things in common, there are also some important distinctions.

If you’re trying to choose between these two Sandals resorts for your honeymoon or next vacation, this comparison of Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay will help.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay Quick Take

Sandals Royal Bahamian is in The Bahamas and Sandals Montego Bay is in Jamaica. Though both are located near vibrant cities, Sandals Montego Bay offers more to do since you also have access to Sandals Royal Caribbean. Sandals Royal Bahamian has a private island. Both have beachfront swim-up rooms.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay Overview

Although on different islands in the Caribbean, both Sandals Royal Bahamian and Montego Bay are in lively cities with plenty to do and see.

Set on the famous Cable Beach in Nassau, Bahamas, the recently renovated Sandals Royal Bahamian has a glamorous feel, new beachfront swim-up suites, and a private offshore island with two beaches, a pool, a Jacuzzi, and a restaurant. It is also close to everything in Nassau.

In Jamaica, Sandals Montego Bay is the first Sandals resort and has been completely renovated for a fresh luxurious feel, with many waterfront rooms and restaurants. It is close to both the airport and all the restaurants, shops, and nightlife of Montego Bay. Guests there also have access to everything at Sandals Royal Caribbean.

Sandals Montego Bay is rated higher on Google: 4.5 vs 4.1 for Sandals Royal Bahamian.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay: Location

Sandals Royal Bahamian and Montego Bay are both centrally located on their respective islands, making them great for those who like to get their vacation started quickly.

Sandals Royal Bahamian is in Nassau, Bahamas, which gets plenty of international flights. It is located about 15 minutes from Lynden Pindling International Airport.

Sandals Montego Bay is located in Montego Bay, Jamaica, just 5 minutes from Sangster International Airport. However, this means you can hear the planes from the resort, but this is mainly during the middle of the day.

You’ll get complimentary transfers to and from the airport at both resorts.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay: Price

Though rates vary throughout the year, Sandals Royal Bahamian and Montego Bay are generally quite similar in price. Currently, Sandals Royal Bahamian starts at $313 per person per night and Sandals Montego Bay starts at $305 per person per night.

Working with a certified Sandals travel specialist can help you save money at both resorts.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay: Amenities and Activities

Both Sandals Royal Bahamian and Montego Bay offer beautiful beaches and complimentary watersports including snorkeling, scuba diving, paddleboarding, kayaking, Hobie Cat sailing, and more. Sandals Royal Bahamian also has windsurfing and water trikes, while Montego Bay has waterskiing and wakeboarding.

Sandals Royal Bahamian offers the exclusive offshore island of Barefoot Cay, with a pool, whirlpool, and swim-up bar; two secluded beaches; an open-air seafood restaurant; and plenty of romantic spots to lounge. You’re also close to the bustling town of Nassau and all the attractions it has to offer, like historic sites, the BahaMar waterpark, markets, and casinos.

There are multiple pools and whirlpools at both resorts. Guests at Sandals Montego Bay have access to all the pools and whirlpools at Sandals Royal Caribbean also—including one on a private island.

Each resort also has land sports including tennis and beach volleyball, as well as a fitness center. Both have nightly entertainment including live shows, theme nights, and more, and both are close to local nightlife options.

There’s an onsite spa at both Sandals Royal Bahamian and Montego Bay, which costs extra.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay: Food and Drink

Sandals Royal Bahamian has 10 restaurants (including one on the private island) and two food trucks. Sandals Montego Bay has 12 restaurants onsite, but 21 restaurants total once you include the ones at Sandals Royal Caribbean.

Sandals Royal Bahamian has 8 bars, including 3 swim-up bars. There are 6 bars including a swim-up bar and an overwater bar at Sandals Montego Bay, which has a vibrant nightlife scene. You can also go to the 5 bars at Royal Caribbean.

Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay: Accommodations

Sandals Royal Bahamian has a variety of butler, club, and luxury-level rooms and suites with ocean or garden views. The elegant West Bay Oceanview Swim-up Butler Suites have walkout patios with views of the ocean, direct access to the zero-entry swim-up pool, and a Tranquility Soaking Tub for Two. Or enjoy your own private pool with the Island Village One Bedroom Butler Villa Suite. These suites come with personal butler service for the ultimate pampering.

At Sandals Montego Bay, most rooms and suites are beachfront. The swankiest include the Beachfront Swim-up Millionaire Suite and the Beachfront Honeymoon Walkout Suite, both with outdoor Tranquility Soaking Tubs for Two™ and personal 24-hour butler service. There are also Crystal Lagoon swim-up suites and a variety of other choices.

After reading our comparison of Sandals Royal Bahamian vs. Montego Bay, which sounds best for you? Let us know in the comments.

And if you’d like our help planning your trip, contact one of our expert travel advisors!