Crunchyroll's Controversial Romance Breaks a Massive Trope in the Most Unexpected Way
Warning: Spoilers for A Condition Called Love episode #11!!
It would normally have been a remarkable event that the official couple in the animeA Condition Called Love kissed before the season finale, which does actually happen. That's because such a development is already a rarity in romance anime. However, it's the fact that the couple in question is Saki and Hotaru, which makes the development even more shockingly noteworthy. Part of this instilled feeling of unexpectedness in most viewers derives from why most critics consider A Condition Called Love to be so controversial. However, the true reason lies in the season's exciting trend – Hotaru's overall newness to love in general.
Although Hotaru's character has grown exponentially over the last few episodes, her initial lack of understanding of what love was and even her inability to actually feel such an emotion before now were so extreme that no amount of character growth would have convinced viewers that she would ever be willing to kiss anyone, even Saki.
The controversy surrounding Saki's purported "love bombing" and controlling nature for critics definitely contributed to their state of befuddlement. However, recent episodes had already confirmed that Hotaru wasn't bothered by Saki's overbearing personality and that she not only tried to accommodate such behavior but some might say, even encouraged such negative feelings by giving Saki chances to express them when he tried to hide them away.
Of course, Hotaru doesn't actually take the initiative to kiss him on the lips herself. She permits Saki in the most submissive way and by using subtle language that has no meaning by itself unless when taken in context with an earlier conversation. Despite the fact she eventually tells him directly in so many words, Hotaru manages it as indirectly as possible, and this had to happen only after her first attempt failed.
Although pretty forward for Hotaru, she initially tries to give her permission by kissing him in a place where there's the least amount of contact – the middle of his head where there's actually hair in the way of his skin, as opposed to kissing his forehead. It's still monumental, regardless, after seeing her many hesitations before, since she gives both verbal and some form of physical consent.
This isn't even taking into account the fact that the whole scene transpires in the 11th episode rather than the season finale, let alone the second to last episode of the first season. If any kiss is to be had in any romance anime, it's normally relegated to the series finale, and if it's to happen earlier, it's normally during the second season's last episode. If it is to transpire in the first season, it's at the very end, not the episode before it.
Of course, some might say that Hotaru has only been accepting of Saki since she's new to being in a relationship and doesn't know that his behavior is inappropriate. However, the fact that she has clearly never been bothered by Saki's actions or personality just makes her a better match for him.
Moreover, when Hotaru does look concerned by Saki's overbearing nature, the series' unprecedented honest delivery allows viewers to learn that her uneasiness came from a place of worry for him or curiosity behind what was causing Saki to act in such a way. It's A Condition Called Love's honesty and the fact that their own idiosyncrasies make them perfect for only each other.