Home Back

Yankees face tough challenge following devastating defeat

newsfinale.com 2024/10/5

This isn’t just a “rough patch,” as manager Aaron Boone occasionally calls it. No, this isn’t just a tough stretch.

This is a Yankees team that looks like it’s in trouble. If this team wants to get where it aims to go, it better start playing like a champion.

More to the point, it needs to wake up.

This team is made up of experienced players who are not performing at their best. The recent 5-3, 10-inning loss against their rivals, the Red Sox, was a particularly tough blow for them. Despite having a packed stadium of fans cheering them on, the team couldn’t secure a win, adding to a string of disappointing performances.

The heartbreaking moments of the game included a home run by Masataka Yoshida in the ninth inning when the team was just one strike away from victory. The situation worsened with another home run by Ceddanne Rafaela in the 10th inning, sealing the Yankees’ defeat.

With only 4 wins in their last 18 games, the team committed a costly mistake that overshadowed the entire game. This error, which is rare even in high school games, will likely be remembered as one of the biggest blunders of the season. What’s concerning is that this blunder came right after another notable mistake in the previous game, showing a pattern of errors that the team needs to address urgently.

With runners on first and third and the force play off after Red Sox first baseman Romy Gonzalez touched first for the second out after fielding Ben Rice’s grounder, Anthony Volpe inexplicably slowed up just before reaching home to watch D.J. LeMahieu run into the final out of the inning. Young Volpe ran like he didn’t understand the rule, but the ultra-experienced LeMahieu certainly should know to get himself into a rundown.

If Boone doesn’t want to take the drastic step of removing starting players while the team is shorthanded and struggling, it may be time he acknowledged that this isn’t just a “rough patch,” as he likes to say, and that spinning things to the positive may not always be the way to go.

I get it. Positivity for the players in the press has been a winning strategy for Boone.

If this doesn’t work out for Boone, he could make it in politics. Or better yet, diplomacy.

Boone continues be counted on to find the kindest way possible to describe every mistake and misplay. While it’s worked well for him — he’s in his seventh year managing the Yankees, the longest tenure in that chair without a championship — sometimes he’s too easy on his troops, which was also the case only the day before.

That’s where we may need to step in. A counterbalance is compelled. Reality needs to resurface. Unwashed honesty can be healthy. (Some more of that below.)

Boone raised the ire of some fans when he mostly gave a pass to Gold Glove backup center fielder Trent Grisham after Grisham’s obvious nonchalance cost the Yankees a base Sunday. (While fielding a single, the normally outstanding outfielder looked like me picking up the Post when it’s delivered at 6 a.m.) And even the day after, Boone continued to suggest the play didn’t look good because Grisham’s so talented and plays with such ease.

While that’s undeniable, it was also a shockingly bad play that deserved to be called out as such.

“I try not to be so emotional because we lost some games or won some games,” Boone explained before Friday’s game. “I have the conversations I think are necessary.”

Give Boone this. On the biggest score, Boone did talk to Grisham, and he apparently told it to him straight. Anyway, Grisham got the message, which is what counts.

“I should have made the play,” Grisham told me, flat out.

Boone handled that one internally. But after yet another unfathomable play, it may be time to try something different.

Managing a team comes down to a series of calculations, and Boone obviously decided long ago to keep things positive while talking to the press about his players. Expressing happy thoughts isn’t hard for Boone as he’s a naturally a very kind person (except to umpires), and sees the bright side in any situation.

Now for some reality. They’re playing at a .278 clip since starting the slide in Boston three weeks ago, and they seem worse. In their last 11 defeats prior to Friday, they hadn’t led. Not for an inning or a moment. It doesn’t take a mathematician to know that’s at least 99 innings without a lead. That feels about right for how things are going.

Boone, meantime, on Friday used the phrase “rough patch” to chronicle the last few weeks, which have been nothing short of abysmal (not a word he’d use). While I like Boone very much (and I’m not just being diplomatic), it’s time someone selected words to fit the situation.

Boone also noted how “unfortunate” it is that their starters’ mistakes are being hit for homers. But that’s what major leaguers do with mistakes, they hit them.

The rotation, once easily the best in baseball, is performing poorly lately. Carlos Rodon, Luis Gil and Marcus Stroman regressed since terrific starts.

Let’s face it, very little is going right beyond 1) Judge, who remains on a Babe Ruth like pace, 2) Juan Soto, who isn’t that far off that pace, and 3) Gerrit Cole being back.

Boone talks like this is just a minor blip. But it sure doesn’t feel that way.

People are also reading