With the release of Presumed Innocent Episode 5, the audience is eager for clarity on what exactly took place during the ending courtroom sequence. One question has been bugging everyone: Did Tommy kill Carolyn? Who was the real killer in Presumed Innocent?

Here is the Presumed Innocent Episode 5 ending explained featuring spoilers.

What happened at the end of Presumed Innocent Episode 5?

At the end of Episode 5, Rusty’s trial begins with intense courtroom drama. Tommy Molto’s opening statement impacts the jury, setting a tense atmosphere.

The episode wraps up with Rusty whispering “f*ck” under his breath, sensing just how serious things have gotten as Tommy’s dramatic opening statement captivates the jury. This sets up a compelling courtroom showdown, with Rusty feeling the heavy weight of proving his innocence despite shaky evidence. The episode shines in its portrayal of the emotional and psychological stress on Rusty and his family as they gear up for the battle in court.

Did Tommy kill Carolyn in Presumed Innocent?

No, Tommy did not kill Carolyn. Rusty was having an affair with Carolyn, giving Tommy a clear motive. However, the Apple TV Plus series has not yet confirmed Tommy as the killer.

Whereas in the original book and movie adaptation of Presumed Innocent, Rusty Sabich’s wife, Barbara, is revealed as the real killer. She murdered Carolyn out of jealousy after discovering Rusty’s affair with her. Desperate to clear his name, Rusty investigates on his own. He uncovers key pieces of evidence and inconsistencies in the timeline, which lead to questioning the initial assumptions about the case.

Subtle clues about Barbara’s behavior and reactions raise suspicions. For example, her nervousness during certain conversations and unexplained absences start to point Rusty toward the truth. Ultimately, Barbara confesses to the murder. She admits that she killed Carolyn out of jealousy and rage after discovering the affair. This confession dramatically changes the case, clearing Rusty’s name.